Abstract

The simultaneous emergence of various technological advancements, such as advanced robotics (AR), big data (BD), the Internet of Things (IoT), cloud computing (CC), and artificial intelligence (AI), has positioned the world, especially developing countries (DCs), on the brink of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. Industry 4.0 technologies are characterized by significant growth in intelligent and autonomous systems. While these technologies offer potential solutions to key development challenges, developing countries face a knowledge gap in understanding the essential aspects, opportunities, and challenges associated with Industry 4.0. Addressing this gap is critical to ensuring DCs are not overwhelmed by the complexities of these technologies. This study systematically analyzes the opportunities and challenges of Industry 4.0 in developing countries, highlighting the common issues and potential benefits these nations should consider when adopting such technologies. The methodology used in this study is a systematic review analysis (SRA), guided by the search, appraisal, synthesis, and analysis (SALSA) framework and the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA) statement. To tackle the challenges of Industry 4.0 in DCs, this paper proposes a strategic framework called "fourth industrial revolution technology for developing countries (FIRTDC)," based on the study’s findings and observations. FIRTDC aims to guide DCs in effectively implementing and adopting Industry 4.0 technologies.

Keyword

Industry 4.0 technology types, Cloud computing, Artificial intelligence, Opportunities and challenges, Developing countries.

Cite this article

Didas M, Mutajwa SA, Chali F.The industry 4.0 technologies, opportunities and challenges for developing countries: a systematic literature review analysis. International Journal of Advanced Computer Research. 2024;14(68):56-88. DOI:10.19101/IJACR.2023.1362046

Refference

[1]Asghar S, Rextina G, Ahmed T, Tamimy MI. The fourth industrial revolution in the developing nations: challenges and road map. Commission on Science and Technology for Sustainable Development in the South. 2020.

[2]Bühler MM, Jelinek T, Nübel K. Training and preparing tomorrows workforce for the fourth industrial revolution. Education Sciences. 2022;12(11):782.

[3]Chaka C. Fourth industrial revolution—a review of applications, prospects, and challenges for artificial intelligence, robotics and blockchain in higher education. Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Learning. 2023; 18:1-39.

[4]Rymarczyk J. Technologies, opportunities and challenges of the industrial revolution 4.0: theoretical considerations. Entrepreneurial Business and Economics Review. 2020;8(1):185-98.

[5]Hsieh CT, Rossi-Hansberg E. The industrial revolution in services. Journal of Political Economy Macroeconomics. 2023; 1(1):3-42.

[6]Manda MI, Ben Dhaou S. Responding to the challenges and opportunities in the 4th Industrial revolution in developing countries. In proceedings of the 12th international conference on theory and practice of electronic governance 2019 (pp. 244-53).

[7]Kayembe C, Nel D. Challenges and opportunities for education in the fourth industrial revolution. African Journal of Public Affairs. 2019; 11(3):79-94.

[8]Peerally JA, Santiago F, De Fuentes C, Moghavvemi S. Towards a firm-level technological capability framework to endorse and actualize the Fourth Industrial Revolution in developing countries. Research Policy. 2022; 51(10):104563.

[9]Manyika J, Chui M, Miremadi M, Bughin J, George K, Willmott P, et al. A future that works: AI, automation, employment, and productivity. Mckinsey Global Institute Research. 2017; 60:1-35.

[10]Li G, Hou Y, Wu A. Fourth Industrial Revolution: technological drivers, impacts and coping methods. Chinese Geographical Science. 2017; 27:626-37.

[11]Enaifoghe A. Digitalisation of African Economies in the fourth industrial revolution: opportunities for growth and industrialisation. African Journal of Development Studies. 2021;11(2).

[12]Akileswaran K, Hutchinson G. Adapting to the 4IR: Africas development in the age of automation. Tony Blair Institute for Global Change. England and Wales. 2019;50.

[13]Manda MI, Backhouse J. Addressing trust, security and privacy concerns in e-government integration, interoperability and information sharing through policy: a case of South Africa. International conference on information resources management 2016 (pp. 1-14). AIS Electronic Library.

[14]Ayentimi DT, Burgess J. Is the fourth industrial revolution relevant to sub-Sahara Africa? Technology Analysis & Strategic Management. 2019; 31(6):641-52.

[15]Islam MA, Jantan AH, Hashim HB, Chong CW, Abdullah MM, Rahman MA, et al. Fourth industrial revolution in developing countries: a case on Bangladesh. Journal of Management Information and Decision Sciences. 2018;21(1):1-9.

[16]Vickers C, Ziebarth NL. Lessons for today from past periods of rapid technological change. 2019.

[17]Liao Y, Deschamps F, Loures ED, Ramos LF. Past, present and future of Industry 4.0-a systematic literature review and research agenda proposal. International Journal of Production Research. 2017; 55(12):3609-29.

[18]Petrillo A, De Felice F, Cioffi R, Zomparelli F. Fourth industrial revolution: Current practices, challenges, and opportunities. Digital Transformation in Smart Manufacturing. 2018; 1:1-20.

[19]Lao L, Li Z, Hou S, Xiao B, Guo S, Yang Y. A survey of IoT applications in blockchain systems: architecture, consensus, and traffic modeling. ACM Computing Surveys. 2020; 53(1):1-32.

[20]Komalavalli C, Saxena D, Laroiya C. Overview of blockchain technology concepts. In handbook of research on blockchain technology 2020 (pp. 349-71). Academic Press.

[21]Yli-Huumo J, Ko D, Choi S, Park S, Smolander K. Where is current research on blockchain technology?—a systematic review. PloS one. 2016; 11(10): e0163477.

[22]Minh D, Wang HX, Li YF, Nguyen TN. Explainable artificial intelligence: a comprehensive review. Artificial Intelligence Review. 2022:1-66.

[23]Chakraborty S, Gonzalez-Triana Y, Mendoza J, Galatro D. Insights on mapping Industry 4.0 and Education 4.0. In frontiers in education 2023 (p. 1150190). Frontiers Media SA.

[24]Hassoun A, Aït-Kaddour A, Abu-Mahfouz AM, Rathod NB, Bader F, Barba FJ, et al. The fourth industrial revolution in the food industry—Part I: Industry 4.0 technologies. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition. 2023; 63(23):6547-63.

[25]Vaidya S, Ambad P, Bhosle S. Industry 4.0–a glimpse. Procedia Manufacturing. 2018; 20:233-8.

[26]Zhong RY, Xu X, Klotz E, Newman ST. Intelligent manufacturing in the context of industry 4.0: a review. Engineering. 2017; 3(5):616-30.

[27]Dahlin E. Are robots stealing our jobs? Socius. 2019; 5:2378023119846249.

[28]Park MA, Yun C, Woo T. Developing a virtual drone flight training contents for beginner. Journal of Korea Game Society. 2019;19(5):53-62.

[29]Bo C. Development and application of instructional module for drone mapping in the free-semester education system. Journal of the Association of Korean Photo-Geographers. 2018;28(4):49-66.

[30]Yoon G, Kim JH, Huh N, Ko HK. Development and application of elementary school STEAM program using drone. Education of Primary School Mathematics. 2017; 20(3):225-35.

[31]Kim EK. Development of underwater drone for coding education and entertainment. The Journal of the Korea Institute of Electronic Communication Sciences. 2018;13(1):237-44.

[32]Ganne E. Can Blockchain revolutionize international trade? Geneva: World Trade Organization; 2018.

[33]Rumi MH, Rashid MH, Makhdum N, Nahid NU. Fourth industrial revolution in Bangladesh: prospects and challenges. Asian Journal of Social Sciences and Legal Studies. 2020; 2(5):104-14.

[34]Ooi KB, Lee VH, Tan GW, Hew TS, Hew JJ. Cloud computing in manufacturing: The next industrial revolution in Malaysia? Expert Systems with Applications. 2018; 93:376-94.

[35]Wang S, Wan J, Li D, Zhang C. Implementing smart factory of industrie 4.0: an outlook. International Journal of Distributed Sensor Networks. 2016; 12(1):3159805.

[36]Klenert D, Fernandez-Macias E, Antón JI. Do robots really destroy jobs? Evidence from Europe. Economic and Industrial Democracy. 2023; 44(1):280-316.

[37]Bahrin MA, Othman MF, Azli NH, Talib MF. Industry 4.0: a review on industrial automation and robotic. Jurnal Teknologi. 2016; 78:6-13.

[38]Chung H. Adoption and development of the fourth industrial revolution technology: features and determinants. Sustainability. 2021; 13(2):871.

[39]Kuhner D, Fiederer LD, Aldinger J, Burget F, Völker M, Schirrmeister RT, et al. A service assistant combining autonomous robotics, flexible goal formulation, and deep-learning-based brain–computer interfacing. Robotics and Autonomous Systems. 2019; 116:98-113.

[40]Adebayo AO, Chaubey MS, Numbu LP. Industry 4.0: the fourth industrial revolution and how it relates to the application of internet of things (IoT). Journal of Multidisciplinary Engineering Science Studies. 2019; 5(2):2477-82.

[41]Xu M, David JM, Kim SH. The fourth industrial revolution: Opportunities and challenges. International Journal of Financial Research. 2018; 9(2):90-5.

[42]Kenett RS, Swarz RS, Zonnenshain A. Systems engineering in the fourth industrial revolution: big data, novel technologies, and modern systems engineering. John Wiley & Sons; 2019.

[43]Lampropoulos G. Artificial intelligence, big data, and machine learning in industry 4.0. In encyclopedia of data science and machine learning 2023 (pp. 2101-9). IGI Global.

[44]Qi C, Fourie A, Chen Q, Zhang Q. A strength prediction model using artificial intelligence for recycling waste tailings as cemented paste backfill. Journal of Cleaner Production. 2018; 183:566-78.

[45]Möller DP. Cybersecurity in digital transformation. In guide to cybersecurity in digital transformation: trends, methods, technologies, applications and best practices 2023 (pp. 1-70). Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland.

[46]De AAJ, Plesker C, Schützer K, Anderl R, Schleich B, Almeida VR. Artificial intelligence-based cyber security in the context of industry 4.0—a survey. Electronics. 2023; 12(8):1920.

[47]Signé L. Africas fourth industrial revolution. Cambridge University Press; 2023.

[48]Chikarkova T. Adoption of augmented and virtual reality in retail: individual intentions. Masters Thesis, Chikarkova, Taisiia. 2018.

[49]Ford S, Despeisse M. Additive manufacturing and sustainability: an exploratory study of the advantages and challenges. Journal of Cleaner Production. 2016; 137:1573-87.

[50]Dilberoglu UM, Gharehpapagh B, Yaman U, Dolen M. The role of additive manufacturing in the era of industry 4.0. Procedia Manufacturing. 2017; 11:545-54.

[51]Thompson MK, Moroni G, Vaneker T, Fadel G, Campbell RI, Gibson I, et al. Design for additive manufacturing: trends, opportunities, considerations, and constraints. CIRP Annals. 2016; 65(2):737-60.

[52]Strange R, Zucchella A. Industry 4.0, global value chains and international business. Multinational Business Review. 2017; 25(3):174-84.

[53]Sahai AK, Rath N. Artificial intelligence and the 4th industrial revolution. In artificial intelligence and machine learning in business management 2021 (pp. 127-43). CRC Press.

[54]Rousseau HP. From Gutenberg to chat GPT: the challenge of the digital university. CIRANO; 2023.

[55]Maphosa V, Maphosa M. Adoption of educational fourth industrial revolution tools pre and post-COVID-19 and the emergence of ChatGPT. In reimagining education-the role of E-learning, Creativity, and Technology in the Post-pandemic Era 2023. Intech Open.

[56]Ndungu N, Signé L. The fourth industrial revolution and digitization will transform Africa into a global powerhouse. Foresight Africa Report. 2020; 5(1):1-77.

[57]Naudé W, Surdej A, Cameron M. Ready for industry 4.0? the case of central and Eastern Europe. Industry 4.0 and Engineering for a Sustainable Future. 2019:153-75.

[58]Leaders YG. World economic forum annual meeting 2016 mastering the fourth industrial revolution. 2016.

[59]Davies R. Industry 4.0: digitalisation for productivity and growth. European Parliamentary Research Service, Belgium. 2015.

[60]Klingenberg C, Antunes J. Industry 4.0: what makes it a revolution. EurOMA 2017. 2017:1-11.

[61]Sharma AK, Bhandari R, Pinca-Bretotean C, Sharma C, Dhakad SK, Mathur A. A study of trends and industrial prospects of Industry 4.0. Materials Today: Proceedings. 2021; 47:2364-9.

[62]Kagermann H. Change through digitization—value creation in the age of Industry 4.0. In management of permanent change 2014 (pp. 23-45). Wiesbaden: Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.

[63]Gap GG. World economic forum. Cologny/Geneva. 2017.

[64]Ogundari K, Awokuse T. Human capital contribution to economic growth in Sub-Saharan Africa: does health status matter more than education? Economic Analysis and Policy. 2018; 58:131-40.

[65]Gallego A, Kurer T. Automation, digitalization, and artificial intelligence in the workplace: implications for political behavior. Annual Review of Political Science. 2022; 25(1):463-84.

[66]Andreoni A, Chang HJ, Labrunie M. Natura non facit saltus: Challenges and opportunities for digital industrialisation across developing countries. The European Journal of Development Research. 2021; 33:330-70.

[67]Ogwo BA. Re-visioning technical vocational education and training (TVET) for the youth in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) and the sustainable development goals (SDGs): prospects and promises within the framework of the ubuntu paradigm. Re-Visioning Education in Africa: Ubuntu-Inspired Education for Humanity. 2018:155-73.

[68]Muchuchuti S, Ebewo P, Muchuchuti KC, Mutoko WR. Jobs 4.0: are Botswana workers ready? Developing Country Studies. 2021; 11(2):29-40.

[69]Sinha D, Roy R. Reviewing cyber-physical system as a part of smart factory in industry 4.0. IEEE Engineering Management Review. 2020; 48(2):103-17.

[70]Zhou K, Liu T, Liang L. From cyber-physical systems to Industry 4.0: make future manufacturing become possible. International Journal of Manufacturing Research. 2016;11(2):167-88.

[71]Ezzahraa Habib F, Bnouachir H, Chergui M, Ammoumou A. Industry 4.0 concepts and implementation challenges: literature review. In 9th international conference on wireless networks and mobile communications 2022 (pp. 1-6). IEEE.

[72]Geryk M. Challenges posed for universities by the Industry 4.0 environment. Cambridge University Press. 2021.

[73]Dean J, Cisse M. Google AI in Ghana. Google. 2018.

[74]Jamil S. Artificial intelligence and journalistic practice: the crossroads of obstacles and opportunities for the Pakistani journalists. Journalism Practice. 2021; 15(10):1400-22.

[75]Gu J, Gouliamos K, Lobonţ OR, Nicoleta-Claudia M. Is the fourth industrial revolution transforming the relationship between financial development and its determinants in emerging economies? Technological Forecasting and Social Change. 2021; 165:120563.

[76]Sutherland E. The fourth industrial revolution–the case of South Africa. Politikon. 2020; 47(2):233-52.

[77]Jules TD. Educational regime complexity: nested governance and multistakeholderism in the fourth industrial revolution. Annual Review of Comparative and International Education. 2017. 2018; 34:139-58.

[78]Antoniuk L, Gernego I, Dyba V, Polishchuk Y, Sybirianska Y. Barriers and opportunities for hi-tech innovative small and medium enterprises development in the 4th industrial revolution era. Problems and Perspectives in Management. 2017; 15(4):100-13.

[79]Ebekozien A, Aigbedion M, Duru OS, Udeagwu OH, Aginah IL. Hazards of wood sawmills in Nigeria’s cities: the role of fourth industrial revolution technologies. Journal of Facilities Management. 2023; 21(1):84-101.

[80]Rojas RA, Rauch E, Vidoni R, Matt DT. Enabling connectivity of cyber-physical production systems: a conceptual framework. Procedia Manufacturing. 2017; 11:822-9.

[81]Qin J, Liu Y, Grosvenor R. A categorical framework of manufacturing for industry 4.0 and beyond. Procedia CIRP. 2016; 52:173-8.

[82]Weerasekara S, Lu Z, Ozek B, Isaacs J, Kamarthi S. Trends in adopting Industry 4.0 for asset life cycle management for sustainability: a keyword co-occurrence network review and analysis. Sustainability. 2022; 14(19):12233.

[83]Perales DP, Valero FA, García AB. Industry 4.0: a classification scheme. Closing the Gap Between Practice and Research in Industrial Engineering. 2018:343-50.

[84]Kadir BA, Broberg O, da Conceição CS. Current research and future perspectives on human factors and ergonomics in Industry 4.0. Computers & Industrial Engineering. 2019; 137:106004.

[85]Bolbot V, Kulkarni K, Brunou P, Banda OV, Musharraf M. Developments and research directions in maritime cybersecurity: a systematic literature review and bibliometric analysis. International Journal of Critical Infrastructure Protection. 2022; 39:100571.

[86]Echchakoui S, Barka N. Industry 4.0 and its impact in plastics industry: a literature review. Journal of Industrial Information Integration. 2020; 20:100172.

[87]Debrah YA, Oseghale RO, Adams K. Human capital, innovation and international competitiveness in Sub-Saharan Africa. Africa’s Competitiveness in the Global Economy. 2018:219-48.

[88]Millington AK. How changes in technology and automation will affect the labour market in Africa. K4D Helpdesk Report, Brighton, UK: Institute of Development Studies. 2017.

[89]Runde D. Is America ready for the fourth industrial revolution? Foreign Policy. 2016.

[90]Selçuk AA. A guide for systematic reviews: PRISMA. Turkish Archives of Otorhinolaryngology. 2019; 57(1):57.

[91]Sarkis-Onofre R, Catalá-López F, Aromataris E, Lockwood C. How to properly use the PRISMA statement. Systematic Reviews. 2021; 10:1-3.

[92]Zervoudi EK. Fourth industrial revolution: opportunities, challenges, and proposed policies. Industrial Robotics-New Paradigms. 2020.

[93]Prisecaru P. Challenges of the fourth industrial revolution. Knowledge Horizons. Economics. 2016; 8(1):57.

[94]Mabasa FD. Fourth industrial revolution: threat and opportunity on employment relations. International conference on public administration and development alternatives 2020(pp. 325-31).

[95]Genkin E, Filin S, Velikorossov V, Kydyrova Z, Anufriyev K. The fourth industrial revolution: personnel, business and state. In E3S web of conferences 2020 (p. 04012). EDP Sciences.

[96]Waidner M, Kasper M. Security in industrie 4.0-challenges and solutions for the fourth industrial revolution. In design, automation & test in Europe conference & exhibition 2016 (pp. 1303-8). IEEE.

[97]Kazmi SJ, Abbas J. Examining the impact of industry 4.0 on labor market in Pakistan. Handbook of Smart Materials, Technologies, and Devices: Applications of Industry 4.0. 2020:1-11.

[98]Zhou K, Liu T, Zhou L. Industry 4.0: towards future industrial opportunities and challenges. In 12th international conference on fuzzy systems and knowledge discovery 2015 (pp. 2147-52). IEEE.

[99]Miah MT, Erdei-Gally S, Dancs A, Fekete-Farkas M. A systematic review of industry 4.0 technology on workforce employability and skills: driving success factors and challenges in South Asia. Economies. 2024; 12(2):35.

[100]Bogoviz AV, Osipov VS, Chistyakova MK, Borisov MY. Comparative analysis of formation of industry 4.0 in developed and developing countries. Industry 4.0: Industrial Revolution of the 21st Century. 2019:155-64.

[101]Joshi S, Sharma M, Luthra S, Garza-Reyes JA, Anbanandam R. An assessment framework to evaluate the critical success factors to Quality 4.0 transition in developing countries: a case experience of sustainable performance of Indian manufacturers. The TQM Journal. 2024.

[102]Joshi S, Sharma M, Bartwal S, Joshi T, Prasad M. Critical challenges of integrating OPEX strategies with I4. 0 technologies in manufacturing SMEs: a few pieces of evidence from developing economies. The TQM Journal. 2022; 36(1):108-38.

[103]Santos AD, Becker AM, Ayala NF, Sant’Anna ÂM. Industry 4.0 as an enabler of sustainability for small and medium enterprises. Academia Revista Latinoamericana de Administración. 2024; 37(2):204-26.

[104]Bilbao-Ubillos J, Camino-Beldarrain V, Intxaurburu-Clemente G, Velasco-Balmaseda E. Industry 4.0, servitization, and reshoring: a systematic literature review. European Research on Management and Business Economics. 2024; 30(1):100234.

[105]Slavic D, Marjanovic U, Medic N, Simeunovic N, Rakic S. The evaluation of industry 5.0 concepts: social network analysis approach. Applied Sciences. 2024; 14(3):1291.

[106]Cordeiro RF, Reis LP, Fernandes JM. A study on the barriers that impact the adoption of Industry 4.0 in the context of Brazilian companies. The TQM Journal. 2024; 36(1):361-84.

[107]Karuppiah K, Sankaranarayanan B, D’Adamo I, Ali SM. Evaluation of key factors for industry 4.0 technologies adoption in small and medium enterprises (SMEs): an emerging economy context. Journal of Asia Business Studies. 2023; 17(2):347-70.

[108]Atieh AM, Cooke KO, Osiyevskyy O. The role of intelligent manufacturing systems in the implementation of Industry 4.0 by small and medium enterprises in developing countries. Engineering Reports. 2023; 5(3): e12578.

[109]Bhagwan N, Evans M. A review of industry 4.0 technologies used in the production of energy in China, Germany, and South Africa. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 2023; 173:113075.

[110]Peter O, Pradhan A, Mbohwa C. Industry 4.0 concepts within the sub–Saharan African SME manufacturing sector. Procedia Computer Science. 2023; 217:846-55.

[111]Pozzi R, Rossi T, Secchi R. Industry 4.0 technologies: critical success factors for implementation and improvements in manufacturing companies. Production Planning & Control. 2023; 34(2):139-58.

[112]Kamble SS, Gunasekaran A. Analysing the role of Industry 4.0 technologies and circular economy practices in improving sustainable performance in Indian manufacturing organisations. Production Planning & Control. 2023; 34(10):887-901.

[113]Zhong Y, Moon HC. Investigating the impact of Industry 4.0 technology through a TOE-based innovation model. Systems. 2023; 11(6):277.

[114]Bai C, Zhou H, Sarkis J. Evaluating Industry 4.0 technology and sustainable development goals–a social perspective. International Journal of Production Research. 2023; 61(23):8094-114.

[115]Yavuz O, Uner MM, Okumus F, Karatepe OM. Industry 4.0 technologies, sustainable operations practices and their impacts on sustainable performance. Journal of Cleaner Production. 2023; 387:135951.

[116]Raj A, Dwivedi G, Sharma A, De SJAB, Rajak S. Barriers to the adoption of industry 4.0 technologies in the manufacturing sector: an inter-country comparative perspective. International Journal of Production Economics. 2020; 224:107546.

[117]Bai C, Dallasega P, Orzes G, Sarkis J. Industry 4.0 technologies assessment: A sustainability perspective. International Journal of Production Economics. 2020; 229:107776.

[118]Jamwal A, Agrawal R, Sharma M, Kumar V, Kumar S. Developing a sustainability framework for Industry 4.0. Procedia CIRP. 2021; 98:430-5.

[119]Chauhan C, Singh A, Luthra S. Barriers to industry 4.0 adoption and its performance implications: an empirical investigation of emerging economy. Journal of Cleaner Production. 2021; 285:124809.

[120]Javaid M, Haleem A, Vaishya R, Bahl S, Suman R, Vaish A. Industry 4.0 technologies and their applications in fighting COVID-19 pandemic. Diabetes & Metabolic Syndrome: Clinical Research & Reviews. 2020; 14(4):419-22.

[121]Saldivar AA, Li Y, Chen WN, Zhan ZH, Zhang J, Chen LY. Industry 4.0 with cyber-physical integration: A design and manufacture perspective. In 21st international conference on automation and computing 2015 (pp. 1-6). IEEE.

[122]Lobova SV, Bykovskaya NV, Vlasova IM, Sidorenko OV. Successful experience of formation of industry 4.0 in various countries. Industry 4.0: Industrial Revolution of the 21st Century. 2019:121-9.

[123]Phadke A, Park WY, Abhyankar N. Providing reliable and financially sustainable electricity access in India using super-efficient appliances. Energy Policy. 2019; 132:1163-75.

[124]Man GM, Man M. Challenges in the fourth industrial revolution. Land Forces Academy Review. 2019; 24(4):303-7.

[125]Simbanegavi W, Patel A, Senbet LW, Mouelhi RB, Gatune J, Amaoko KY, et al. World of work in the 4th industrial revolution: inclusive and structural transformation for a better Africa. Fourth Industrial Revolution Africa Employment Creation, HSRC Research Outputs. 2019.

[126]Postelnicu C, Calea S. The fourth industrial revolution, global risks, local challenges for employment. Montenegrin Journal of Economics. 2019; 15(2):195-206.

[127]Arntz M, Gregory T, Zierahn U. Technology and jobs in the fourth industrial revolution. In IZA workshop: labor productivity and the digital economy 2017.

[128]Mdluli S, Makhupe O. Defining leadership competencies needed for the fourth industrial revolution: leadership competencies 4.0. Africa Expansion Project. 2017;13.

[129]Davis N, Samans R. Advancing human-centred economic progress in the fourth industrial revolution. World Economic Forum. 2017.

[130]Ozkan-Ozen YD, Kazancoglu Y. Analysing workforce development challenges in the Industry 4.0. International Journal of Manpower. 2022; 43(2):310-33.

[131]Chalmers D, MacKenzie NG, Carter S. Artificial intelligence and entrepreneurship: Implications for venture creation in the fourth industrial revolution. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice. 2021; 45(5):1028-53.

[132]Ćwiklicki M, Klich J, Chen J. The adaptiveness of the healthcare system to the fourth industrial revolution: a preliminary analysis. Futures. 2020; 122:102602.

[133]Shava E, Hofisi C. Challenges and opportunities for public administration in the fourth industrial revolution. African Journal of Public Affairs. 2017; 9(9):203-15.

[134]Islam MF, Awal MR, Zaman R. The concurrent journey of sustainable development goals (SDGs) and fourth industrial revolution (4IR): paradoxical or parallel. SDMIMD Journal of Management. 2022; 13(1):61.

[135]Effoduh JO. The fourth industrial revolution by Klaus Schwab. The Transnational Human Rights Review 3. World Economic Forum. 2017.

[136]Rotatori D, Lee EJ, Sleeva S. The evolution of the workforce during the fourth industrial revolution. Human Resource Development International. 2021; 24(1):92-103.

[137]Alade K, Windapo AO. Developing effective 4IR leadership framework for construction organisations. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management. 2021; 28(5):1377-96.

[138]The future of jobs and skills in Africa: preparing the region for the fourth industrial revolution. Geneva: World Economic Forum. 2017.

[139]Müller JM, Kiel D, Voigt KI. What drives the implementation of Industry 4.0? the role of opportunities and challenges in the context of sustainability. Sustainability. 2018; 10(1):247.

[140]Waslo R, Lewis T, Hajj R, Carton R. Industry 4.0 and cybersecurity: managing risk in an age of connected production. Deloitte University Press. 2017.

[141]Basl J, Kopp J. Study of the readiness of czech companies to the industry 4.0. Journal of Systems Integration. 2017; 8(3):40.

[142]Kiel D, Müller JM, Arnold C, Voigt KI. Sustainable industrial value creation: Benefits and challenges of industry 4.0. International Journal of Innovation Management. 2017; 21(08):1740015.

[143]Pereira AC, Romero F. A review of the meanings and the implications of the industry 4.0 concept. Procedia Manufacturing. 2017; 13:1206-14.

[144]Bal HÇ, Erkan Ç. Industry 4.0 and competitiveness. Procedia Computer Science. 2019; 158:625-31.

[145]De SJAB, Jabbour CJ, Foropon C, Godinho FM. When titans meet–Can industry 4.0 revolutionise the environmentally-sustainable manufacturing wave? the role of critical success factors. Technological Forecasting and Social Change. 2018; 132:18-25.

[146]Malomane R, Musonda I, Okoro CS. The opportunities and challenges associated with the implementation of fourth industrial revolution technologies to manage health and safety. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2022; 19(2):846.

[147]Oesterreich TD, Teuteberg F. Understanding the implications of digitisation and automation in the context of Industry 4.0: a triangulation approach and elements of a research agenda for the construction industry. Computers in Industry. 2016; 83:121-39.

[148]Moloi D, Zibani S, Makhubela R. Fourth industrial revolution and the future of government. National Treasure. 2018; 11:1-34.

[149]Van RNJ, Telukdarie A, Dhamija P. Society 4.0 applied in Africa: advancing the social impact of technology. Technology in Society. 2019; 59:101125.

[150]Bayode A, Van DPJA, Ramphal RR. 4th industrial revolution: challenges and opportunities in the South African context. In conference on science, engineering and waste management 2019 (pp. 174-80).

[151]Gaspar M, Julião J, Cruz M. Organizational strategies induced by the fourth industrial revolution: workforce awareness and realignment. In innovation, engineering and entrepreneurship 2019 (pp. 330-6). Springer International Publishing.

[152]Lins T, Oliveira RA. Energy efficiency in industry 4.0 using SDN. In IEEE 15th international conference on industrial informatics 2017 (pp. 609-14). IEEE.

[153]Mahachi JJ, Moghayedi A, Michell K. Investigating the effects of innovative technologies on the delivery of south African affordable housing. In construction industry development board postgraduate research conference 2022 (pp. 414-24). Cham: Springer International Publishing.